Most people who become migraine

Answer choices

1. A

   Correct86% picked this

   Most good-tempered dogs were vaccinated against rabies as puppies. Therefore, a puppy that is vaccinated against rabies is likely to

   Why this is right

   Most GTD’s were vaccinated as puppies. Thus, if you’re vaccinated as puppy, you’ll likely be a GTD.

   Skill tested: Parallel Flaw · how this choice captures the argument's function is the move to repeat next time.

   86%
2. B

   Valid / Bad Conclusion Match7% picked this

   Most vicious dogs were ill-treated when young. Hence it can be concluded that a pet owner whose dog is vicious is likely to have

   This does not reverse the Most statement. It actually correctly reasons that if someone is A, they’re likely B. Most vicious were ill-treated when young. Thus, if vicious then probably ill-treated when young.

   7%
3. C

   Bad Conclusion Match2% picked this

   Most well-behaved dogs have undergone obedience training. Thus, if a dog has not undergone obedience training, it will

   The conclusion of the original said, “Thus if you’re B, you’re likely to be A”. The conclusion of this is saying, “Thus, if you’re not-B, then you’re not-A”. Most well behaved had training. Thus, if you didn’t have training, you won’t be well behaved.

   2%
4. D

   Bad Conclusion Match1% picked this

   Most of the pets taken to veterinarians are dogs. Therefore, it stands to reason that dogs are more prone to illness or

   Out Of Scope: "prone to illness or accident"The conclusion of the original said, “thus if you’re B, you’re likely to be A”. This conclusion is saying, “if you’re B, then you’re C”. Instead of looping back to the idea of “taken to veterinarians”, it introduces a third (albeit related) concept of “prone to illness or accident”.

   1%
5. E

   Valid / Bad Conclusion Match3% picked this

   Most puppies are taken from their mothers at the age of eight weeks. Thus, a puppy that is older than eight weeks is likely

   The conclusion does not reverse the original claim. Instead of saying, “Thus, if you were taken from your mother at eight weeks, you’re probably a puppy”, it begins by saying “Thus, if you’re a puppy older than eight weeks”. This argument is actually valid. If we say “Most American children know their alphabet by age 5”, then we’d be allowed to infer “If you’re an American child older than 5, then you probably already know your alphabet”.

   3%