Whenever a major political scandal erupts before an election and voters blame the scandal on all parties about equally, virtually all incumbents, from whatever party, seeking reelection are returned to office.
Given that
When voters blame a pre-election scandal on all parties about equally, nearly all incumbents of every party are returned to office.
Why is it that
When voters blame the scandal on one party, that party's incumbents are likely to lose to challengers from other parties?
Evaluate
The contrast is odd on its face. Scandal is scandal, and incumbents are incumbents, yet voters punish in one case and forgive in the other. The stem asks for a principle guiding the voters that would make both reactions consistent.
Look at what differs. When one party is blamed, voters have a way to punish the responsible party: vote in challengers from the other parties. When every party is blamed, voting out an incumbent only installs someone from another equally guilty party, so there is no way to penalize the responsible side by switching. A principle that says voters aim to punish the responsible party, where that is possible, explains both outcomes. Principles about individual responsibility, about which judgment is more accurate, about every blamed incumbent losing, or about the quality of challengers do not fit both halves.
Goal
Find the principle that voters penalize the party responsible for a scandal whenever they can.