Reading Comprehension

PT128 · S4 · P2 · Q7 Woody Allen

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

Save & drill this skill — build targeted practice sets from questions like this one
Video walkthroughs — watch every question solved step by step
81 official LSATs — as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Start practicing free

ln filmmaker Woody Allen's Deconstructing Harry, the writer Harry Block is presented as extremely neurotic and narcissistic.

Topic

Woody Allen's films

Framework

Noteworthy Figure/Phenomenon

Main Point

A theme present throughout Allen's career is critiquing people whose lives are dedicated to and obsessed with art.

Summary

P1 - Example 1, Deconstructing Harry

This paragraph opens with a vignette of this movie's central character, and then we get our Purpose Pivot in the 3rd sentence.

While the narcissism is exaggerated for comic effect, the effect is not simply comic: this film is emblematic of Allen's career.

In Noteworthy Figure passages, we're attuned for moments that sound like the author is crystallizing the essence of the artist. What was their unique angle / style / voice all about? So this sentence looks like an early nominee for our Most Valuable Sentence.

P2 - Example 2, Stardust Memories

This paragraph begins with "For instance", so we know it's supposed to be illustrating a Big Idea we just heard. We would remind ourselves of the big idea merely documenting their private suffering and fobbing it off as art", and our author suggests in the final line of this paragraph that Woody Allen probably struggles with this himself, worrying that he himself is guilty of this critique.

P3 - Example 3, Manhattan

Our first sentence again reinforces our main theme: a denigratory (to denigrate is to insult / debase) take on the artistic enterprise.

The themes in this movie again involve pretentious, narcissistic artists who try to turn their own woes into tragic art.

P4 - No Cause, No Effect strengtheners

This last paragraph provides a handful of examples to demonstrate that when Allen's characters are not narcissistic artists, he portrays them much more happily and gives them good outcomes in the story.

Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of the passage?

Correct
The theme of the neurotic
Why this is right
It's a little weird to me that Deconstructing is making it into the Main Point sentence, since that movie is one of a handful of examples, but it's not part of the main clause. The main clause is "The theme of neurotic/narcisstic artists is one that Allen has explored throughout his career". That's a great match for the last two sentences of the first paragraph.
Skill tested: Main Point · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.
72% picked this
Woody Allen's films suggest, by
Wrong Emphasis
This answer is making it seem like the author's focus was in spreading the message of Woody Allen's films. The message this answer portrays is mostly accurate -- though it's a little too strong to say "pursuit of an artistic life leads to unhappiness." Woody Allen hates a life that's "dedicated to and obsessed with art" and he hates pretentious / narcissistic artists. But it's not clear that he thinks that anyone pursuing an artistic life falls into those trappings. More importantly, the author's Big Picture goal is explicitly identifying a common motif that runs through Woody's films. It's less clear in the phrasing of this answer than in the correct answer that this depiction of artists is a "concentrated reprise of a theme present throughout his career".
18% picked this
Deconstructing Harry, like many of
Wrong Tone
According to this answer, Woody Allen's message is that great artists are heroic -- the great ones are willing to put in the sacrifice needed to create enduring works. Meanwhile, the actual message is that obsessive art / art lovers are narcissists and annoying.
1% picked this
Woody Allen's career indicates that,
Woody Allen Trap Too Strong: most
Woody Allen, the actor, is most frequently described as "neurotic" in the real world, so this answer is trying to rope people into using their outside knowledge that Woody himself is probably pretty similar to the characters that are negatively profiled in these movies. But this author / this passage doesn't give us any way to support the idea that Woody Allen is modeling this after himself (other than one tiny reference in the last sentence of the 2nd paragraph). Even if we thought the passage was saying that Woody uses his own experiences for his most acclaimed works, we can't find the passage saying "most artists" have the same experience.
7% picked this
Woody Allen's films show that
Too Strong: unavoidably Wrong Tone
The fact that this answer makes it seem like one of Woody's points is that artists can produce works of great beauty in power seems totally unjustified. In all the examples of negative portrayals of artists, was there any point where we heard that the films were emphasizing the great beauty and power of the works of these narcissists? Also, "unavoidably" is not supportable.
1% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

Save and practice this skill

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free