Reading Comprehension

PT142 · S3 · P1 · Q4 The Decline of Perfumery

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

  • Save & drill this skill build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Given the amount of time and effort that curators, collectors, dealers, scholars, and critics spend on formulating judgments of taste in relation to oil paintings, it seems odd that so few are prepared to apply some of the same skills in exploring works of art that stimulate another sense altogether: that of smell.

Topic

Why great perfume isn’t considered a serious art form—despite strong similarities to painting and music.

Framework

Challenge Position (The author challenges the position that perfume is not taken seriously as art.)

Main Point

Even though perfume, like painting and music, is a sophisticated art that stimulates our senses and emotions, it isn’t taken as seriously as visual or musical arts, partly due to commercialization and neglect by art professionals. *Most Valuable Sentence*: "Why is great perfume not taken more seriously?" (end of P1 and developed throughout passage) and (P3).

P1: Surprise at Perfume’s Neglect by Art Professionals

Despite how much time experts spend evaluating visual arts, almost nobody in the art world approaches perfume with the same seriousness, even though some perfumes are true masterpieces.

P2: Comparing Painting and Perfumery Techniques

The passage draws parallels between painting and perfume-making, describing how both involve crafting complex creations from natural and synthetic materials, with both changing over time.

P3: Perfume as a Sophisticated, Emotional Art

Just as painters create moods and stories with color, skilled perfumers (“noses”) use scents to evoke deep emotional memories and experiences—making perfume as intimate and powerful as painting or music.

4.

The passage provides the most support for which one of the following statements about art?

  1. Correct

    A work of art can

    Why this is right

    Since this has such lovably weak wording (a work of art can do X), we would definitely prioritize researching it on a first pass. This aligns with the end of the 3rd paragraph, where the author is explaining why perfumes are no less an art form than other commonly-recognized art forms, and where she discusses the aesthetic experience they're creating: A brilliant perfumer may thus devise an imaginary world no less powerful, or intimate, than that of a great composer or painter, and in calling on our capacity to discover there some memory of childhood or of a long-forgotten experience, perfumers are in the same business as the artist who creates the illusion of life on canvas. What same business are they both in? Making art.

    Skill tested: Inference · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.

    86% picked this

  2. In any work of art,

    Too Strong: any

    It's too strong to say that every single work of art has a detectable, harmonious combination of many small sensations. The author thought that this characterization applies both to oil paintings and perfumes, which are art. But we don't know if she thinks it applies to every single work of art. Also, the author tells us that some combinations are designed to be discordant, not harmonious.

    10% picked this

  3. A work of art will

    Too Strong: inevitably fail

    It's too strong to say that every single work of art created for the sake of commercial success will inevitably fail. Jordan Peele, for example, has directed three movies ("Get Out" / "Us" / "Nope") that were designed for the sake of commercial success and, according to film critics, succeed greatly as works of art.

    3% picked this

  4. The best works of art

    Too Strong: best

    The author never makes any statement saying that any work of art that could be considered among "the best" also improves with age (the farther you get from its release, the better it is).

    1% picked this

  5. Some forms of art are

    Unsupported Comparison: superior

    Like (A), the soft language of (E) would make us consider it more thoughtfully on a first pass. But, there's just no support in the passage for the author ranking one form of art higher than another. Overall, the author is trying to get people to consider perfume a form of art on the same level as other forms of art.

    1% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free