Passage A Research concerning happiness and wealth reveals a paradox: at any one time richer people report higher levels of happiness than poorer people in the same society report, and yet over time advanced societies have not grown happier as they have grown richer. Apparently, people are comparing their income with with actual income. Two phenomena—habituation and rivalry—push up the norm.
When our living standards increase, we love it initially but then we adjust and it makes little difference. For example, if we ask people with different incomes what income they consider sufficient, the “required income” correlates strongly with their actual income: a rise in actual income causes a roughly equivalent rise in on the absolute level of wages but rises if wages rapidly increase.
We do not have the same experience with other aspects of our lives. We do not foresee how we adjust to material possessions, so we the expense of leisure.
Now consider the phenomenon of rivalry. In a study conducted by Solnick and Hemenway, people were asked to choose between prices held constant:
A. You earn $50,000 a year while everyone $25,000;
B. You earn $100,000 a year while others
The majority chose the first. They were happy to be poorer, provided position improved.
And indeed, how people compare to their “reference group”—those most like them—is crucial for happiness. In East Germany, for example, living standards have soared since 1990, but the level of happiness has plummeted because people now than with people in other Soviet bloc countries.
Passage B Does the Solnick and Hemenway study mean that we care most about one-upmanship? Perhaps out of our primeval past comes the urge to demonstrate our superiority in order to help ensure mating prospects, keeping our genetic lines going. Still from having a bigger house than our neighbors.
This theory may sound good and is commonly heard, but it is not the explanation best supported by the evidence. Rather, the data show that earning more makes people happier because relative prosperity successful, that they have created value.
If two people feel equally successful, they will be equally happy even if their incomes differ greatly. Of course, people who earn more generally view themselves as successful. But it is the success—not the money per se—that provides the happiness. We use material wealth but that we are prosperous because we create value.
What scholars often portray as an ignoble tendency—wanting to have more than others—is really evidence of a desire to create value. Wanting to create value benefits that it also brings happiness.
What this question is testing
Your task
Describe how the argument proceeds — the technique it uses to reach its conclusion.
Common trap
Answers that describe a method the argument doesn't actually use.
Winning move
Track the role each statement plays, then match that to the choice describing the same moves.
Reading along? Open the full official question in LawHub — we show a fragment here and keep the reasoning in our own words.