Passage A Until recently, conservationists were often complacent about the effect of nonindigenous plant and animal species on the ecosystems they invade. Many shared Charles Elton’s view, introduced in his 1958 book on invasive species, that disturbed habitats are most vulnerable to new arrivals because they contain fewer or less vigorous native problems and high damage and control costs generated by these invasions merit serious concern.
Invasive plants profoundly affect ecosystems and threaten biodiversity throughout the world. For example, to the untrained eye, the Everglades National Park in Florida appears wild and natural. Yet this and other unique ecosystems are being degraded as surely as if by chemical pollution. In Florida, forests are growing where none existed before. introduction of Scotch broom plants led to the disappearance of a diverse set of native reptiles.
Passage B The real threat posed by so-called invasive species isn’t against nature but against humans’ ideas of what nature is supposed to be. Species invasion is not a zero-sum game, with new species replacing old ones at a one-to-one ratio. Rather, and with critical exceptions, it is a positive-sum game, in new species and lose few or no native species, the overall species count goes up.
Invasions don’t cause ecosystems to collapse. Invasions may radically alter the components of an ecosystem, perhaps to a point at which the ecosystem becomes less valuable or engaging to humans. But 50 years of study has failed to identify a clear ecological difference between an ecosystem rich in native species and one make ecosystems shrink or disappear. They simply transform them into different ecosystems.
When the issue is phrased as one of ecosystem destruction, the stakes are stark: we choose between nature’s life and nature’s death. In actuality, introduced species present a continuum. A few species do cause costly damage and tragic extinctions. But most plant and animal species simply blend in harmlessly. The issue they nature but rather what kind of nature we will have around us.
What this question is testing
Your task
Describe how the argument proceeds — the technique it uses to reach its conclusion.
Common trap
Answers that describe a method the argument doesn't actually use.
Winning move
Track the role each statement plays, then match that to the choice describing the same moves.
Reading along? Open the full official question in LawHub — we show a fragment here and keep the reasoning in our own words.