Tania: A good art critic

Answer choices

1. A

   Half Scope17% picked this

   art is not simply a

   We know that Monique agrees with this, but we don't know if Tania thinks that art is only a passion, or if it's a passion in addition to other stuff.

   17%
2. B

   Correct60% picked this

   good art criticism is sometimes

   Why this is right

   Tania says NO to this claim. A good art critic is not fair/unbiased. Monique says YES, because the best critics shed their biases and use general principles to make their criticism.

   Skill tested: Agree/Disagree · how this choice captures the argument's function is the move to repeat next time.

   60%
3. C

   Both Disagree (?) / Out of Scope: "should"13% picked this

   art critics should not feel emotion

   They both expect critics to passionately / emotionally engage. And neither of them are even using "should" language.

   13%
4. D

   Too Strong / Both Agree (?)5% picked this

   fairness generally requires minimizing the influence

   We can't infer whether either person thinks that fairness usually, in more than 50% of cases, requires minimizing bias. It's likely, though, that both authors would agree that fair generally means unbiased.

   5%
5. E

   Too Strong: "the most important aspect"5% picked this

   the passionate engagement of the art critic with the artwork is the most important aspect

   Neither person discusses what is the most important part of art criticism, so we wouldn't be able to infer their positions on "#1 aspect".

   5%