Reading ComprehensionDifficulty: Hard

PT125 S1 P2 Q9 Explanation

Drilling Muds

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

TopicsInferenceScience

Keep going in LSAT Lab

  • Save & drill this skill build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Full official LSAT questions are available through LawHub. This page provides LSAT Lab's explanation, strategy, and review tools without republishing the full official question.

Passage

Passage A Drilling fluids, including the various mixtures known as drilling muds, play essential roles in oil-well drilling. As they are circulated down through the drill pipe and back up the well itself, they lubricate the drill bit, bearings, and drill pipe; clean and cool the drill bit as it cuts into pressure, and composition of the drilling fluid; and maintain well pressure to control cave-ins.

Drilling muds are made of bentonite and other clays and polymers, mixed with a fluid to the desired viscosity. By far the largest ingredient of drilling muds, by weight, is barite, a very heavy mineral of density 4.3 to 4.6. It is also used as an inert filler in some as the “barium meal” administered before X-raying the digestive tract.

Over the years individual drilling companies and their expert drillers have devised proprietary formulations, or mud “recipes,” to deal with specific types of drilling jobs. One problem in studying the effects of drilling waste discharges is that the drilling fluids are made from a range of over 1,000, sometimes toxic, ingredients— many words, and many of them kept secret by companies or individual formulators.

Passage B Drilling mud, cuttings, and associated chemicals are normally released only during the drilling phase of a well’s existence. These discharges are the main environmental concern in offshore oil production, and their use is tightly regulated. The discharges are closely monitored controlled as a condition of the operating permit.

One type of mud—water-based mud (WBM)—is a mixture of water, bentonite clay, and chemical additives, and is used to drill shallow parts of wells. It is not particularly toxic to marine organisms and disperses readily. Under current regulations, it can be dumped directly overboard. Companies typically recycle WBMs until their period of hours, dump the entire batch into the sea.

For drilling deeper wells, oil-based mud (OBM) is normally used. The typical difference from WBM is the high content of mineral oil (typically 30 percent). OBMs also contain greater concentrations of barite, a powdered heavy mineral, and a number of additives. OBMs have a greater potential for negative environmental impact, partly because fluids may be discharged overboard, and then only mixtures up to a specified maximum oil content.

What this question is testing

Inference

Your task

Find what must be true based on what the passage or stimulus states.

Common trap

Answers that are plausible or likely but not actually guaranteed by the text.

Winning move

Keep only the choice the statements fully support — eliminate anything that requires an extra assumption.

Reading along? Open the full official question in LawHub — we show a fragment here and keep the reasoning in our own words.

The question
9.

Which one of the following can be most reasonably inferred from the two passages taken together, but not

Answer choices

  1. Too Strong: most damaging19% picked this

    Barite is the largest ingredient of drilling muds, by weight, and also the

    We do know from Passage A that barite is the largest ingredient by weight. We do not know from Passage B that barite is the most damaging. We know that barite may damage scallops, but we also know that the mineral oil in drilling muds may have toxic effects. We can't conclusively say that barite is the most damaging.

  2. Correct61% picked this

    Although barite can be harmful to marine organisms, it can be consumed

    Why this is right

    Passage B tells us that barite may impact some organisms, particularly scallops. Passage A tells us that barite appears as an inert filler in foods and in a medical treatment for X-raying the digestive tract. Do we know that consuming these things is "safe" for humans? No, not quite. But this is still our best available answer. If we use a little common sense and dial down the cynicism, then something used as a filler in food or as a pre-game drink for a medical diagnostic, then it should be something safe.

    Skill tested: Inference · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.

  3. Unsupported Comparison5% picked this

    Offshore drilling is more damaging to the environment than is

    Neither passage compares offshore to land-based drilling.

  4. Out of Scope: needs to be10% picked this

    The use of drilling muds needs to be more tightly controlled

    Neither passage expresses an opinion about what should be done. Passage A seems to find the complex, opaque recipes of drilling mud to be a problem when it comes to assessing environmental impact, but we can't find anything that sounds like a plea for more govt control. Passage B seems to just describe existing regulations in a way that connotes a general comfort level with the ways things are.

  5. Unsupported Causal Relationship5% picked this

    If offshore drilling did not generate cuttings, it would be less harmful

    Passage A never mentions cuttings or specific harm to the environment, so we would never be pulling something from passage A to support this. Moreover, Passage B has not identified cuttings as inherently harmful, so drilling that did NOT generate cuttings wouldn't be LESS harmful. It's the OBMs that are still stuck on the cuttings, after the cuttings have been sieved, that are potentially causing harm.

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free