Reading Comprehension

PT121 · S3 · P2 · Q7 Gluck’s Poetry

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

Save & drill this skill — build targeted practice sets from questions like this one
Video walkthroughs — watch every question solved step by step
81 official LSATs — as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

The poet Louise Glück has said that she feels comfortable writing within a tradition often characterized as belonging only to male poets.

Topic

Louise Glück's approach to poetic tradition, gender, and the literary canon.

Framework

Present Debate — The passage lays out two main perspectives: Glück's on embracing the poetic canon as universal, and her critics' call for a uniquely female poetic tradition.

Main Point

Louise Glück believes she can belong to and creatively work within a poetic tradition often considered male by embracing its themes as universal, whereas some critics argue that using such a tradition is problematic for women poets; Glück counters that striving for an exclusively female perspective can be just as limiting. (The Most Valuable Sentences are in the opening and closing of the final paragraph.)

P1: Glück’s Embrace of the Canon

Louise Glück feels at home in a poetical tradition usually thought of as male-dominated, viewing it as her rightful inheritance, and she admires and respects its legacy, even as many women poets reject it for being historically exclusive.

P2: The Universality of Poetic Themes

Glück’s own experiences—reading poetry before living through its themes—support her belief that poetic subjects like loss and mortality are universal and not confined to one gender or group.

P3: Critics’ Counterarguments

Some critics argue that the so-called universality is naive, believing that gendered histories inevitably shape a poet's experience, and that traditional forms are inadequate for representing female voices; they suggest women poets need to create new forms and voices.

Based on the passage, with which one of the following statements regarding the poetic tradition in English would Glück be most likely to agree?

This tradition is somewhat diminished
Out of Scope: somewhat diminished
None of the available details include Gluck saying anything negative about this poetic tradition, so we have no support for the negativity of "somewhat diminished".
1% picked this
This tradition transcends its social
Out of Scope: transcends context
None of the available details include Gluck saying anything like "this tradition transcends when and where it actually occurred". She makes it sound like "it's the tradition of my language and thus it's my inheritance", which sounds more like it's a tradition that is limited by language.
15% picked this
The male-dominated aspect of this
Too Strong: only / uniquely Too Negative
None of the available details includes Gluck saying anything negative about this poetic tradition, so we have no support for the negativity of "male-dominated can be overcome only if X". We also know from later in the passage that Gluck doesn't like the idea of developing a uniquely female voice. She just wants poets to be poets. If a poet is female, then their female-ness will naturally come out at times.
1% picked this
The view of this tradition
Too Strong: necessary
She never says anything that sounds as strong as, "you can't be a successful poet unless you view this tradition as an inheritance", which is what this answer says.
4% picked this
Correct
This tradition, though male dominated,
Why this is right
Well, this isn't an obvious or lovable answer. It doesn't directly reinforce any of the four things she is quoted saying in the first paragraph. But this answer makes two very moderate claims, both of which we assume Gluck would sign off on. Would she agree that this tradition is male dominated? Sure. She has told people, "I'm comfortable writing within a tradition often described as belonging to only males. My gender didn't keep me from appreciating the male poets." Would she agree that the poetry addresses universal subjects? Yes, the 2nd paragraph supports this. She could see in this poetry "the great themes and subjects of poetry". She says that subjects like loss, time, desire "are timeless, available to readers of any gender". The subjects the males wrote on don't belong to any gender. They are the great human subjects. "Issues of gender distinction fade behind the presence of this universal reality". This answer makes two separate claims, both of which are things we can see Gluck agreeing to. But the tension of the two claims also lines up. "Although the tradition is male dominated (Gluck would concede), it addresses universal subjects (which she emphasizes when explaining why she, as a woman, had no trouble falling in love with this male-written poetry and has no trouble considering her own poetry as belonging to the same tradition)."
Skill tested: Non-Author Opinion · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.
79% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

Save and practice this skill

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free