Reading Comprehension

PT112 · S2 · P1 · Q1 Computer Conferences

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

Save & drill this skill — build targeted practice sets from questions like this one
Video walkthroughs — watch every question solved step by step
81 official LSATs — as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Start practicing free

Traditionally, members of a community such as a town or neighborhood share a common location and a sense of necessary interdependence that includes, for example, mutual respect and emotional support.

Topic

Can online computer conferences truly substitute for traditional, place-based communities?

Framework

Old / New (with elements of Challenge Position)

Main Point

While online computer conferences can foster respectful and supportive relationships with their own etiquette, they ultimately lack the essential qualities found in traditional geographic communities—such as diversity and involuntary participation—and are not a true substitute. (The main point is encapsulated in the last sentence of the passage.)

P1: Traditional Communities vs. Modern Changes

This paragraph introduces what traditional communities are and highlights how technology and modern social alienation reduce those classic interactions, with some advocates suggesting that new, tech-based "computer conferences" could take their place.

P2: How Advocates Say Online Conferences Function as Communities

We hear specifics about how computer conferences work: people bond over shared interests, develop their own online etiquettes and codes, and even support each other emotionally—almost as if it’s a real community.

P3: Why Computer Conferences Aren't Real Communities

Here, the author pushes back, explaining that online conferences are limited—they’re accessible only to those with resources and knowledge, cater to self-selected participants, and lack the diversity and inadvertent mingling that happen in real communities. The author concludes that these online forums, while comfortable, could actually isolate people from the richness of real-life, local engagement.

Which one of the following most accurately expresses the central idea of the passage?

Because computer conferences attract participants
Opposite
The main clause of this answer reads, [Computer] conferences can substitute effectively for certain interactions .. within actual communities. We were looking for the main clause to be the opposite of that, "Computer conferences fall short of being effective substitutes for community."
2% picked this
Since increased participation in computer
Wrong Emphasis: wrong central topic
The main clause of this answer says, Members of actual communities are returning to traditional interactions. We were looking for, Computer conferences fall short of being a true community. This main clause isn't similar at all to what we were looking for. It's on a completely different topic from "computer conferences".
0% picked this
Because participants in computer conferences
Too Narrow Contradicted
The main clause of this is saying, The interactions [of people in computer conferences] can't be as respectful and supportive as were traditional interactions within actual communities. We were looking for, Computer conferences fall short of being true communities. This answer would be giving us a premise that supports the conclusion we're looking for. Why do computer conferences fall short of being true communities? One reason is [this answer choice], that participants aren't as respectful and supportive as actual community members historically have been. Since we're looking for the Main Point of the passage, we need the Conclusion not part of the supporting evidence. But in this case this Premise is also contradicted by the first sentence of the final paragraph, in which the author makes it seem like the positive traits that computer conferences do have are being supportive and being respectful of each other.
3% picked this
Correct
Although computer conferences offer some
Why this is right
The main clause here is that, the lack of diversity among participants in a computer conference makes it so that computer conferences are not like actual communities. We finally found the clause we were looking for! They hid it at the end of the main clause, after an introductory modifier. Can we sign off on the rest of the details? Did the author say that computer conferences offer some of the same benefits that actual communities do? Yes, in our Most Valuable Sentence (the first sentence of the final paragraph), the author concedes some benefits of computer conferences (they can be respectful and supportive). Did the author cite 'lack of diversity' as the primary reason for why computer conferences fall short of being a real community? Sure. Immediately after claiming that these conferences fall short of being real communities, she talks about how they discriminate along educational and economic lines. She also says in the middle of the last paragraph that computer conferences "are a self-selecting group. Actual communities, on the other hand, are nonintentional."
Skill tested: Main Point · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.
86% picked this
Even if access to computer
Too Strong: still won't be acceptable
This main clause is very temptingly similar to what we were looking for: Computer conferences will not be acceptable substitutes for actual communities. However, the tense is different. Our Most Valuable Sentence (start of 3rd paragraph) is saying that "these conferences fall short", not "these conferences will fall short". The main point is about what's currently happening, not about some hypothetical world in which computer conferences are more diverse. The choice that (D) vs. (E) offers us is this: Because they lack diversity, computer conferences aren't an acceptable substitute for an actual community. vs. Even if they one day attain diversity, computer conferences still won't be an acceptable substitute for an actual community.
9% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

Save and practice this skill

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free