Reading Comprehension

PT110 · S4 · P4 · Q25 African American Rice Cultivation

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

  • Save & drill this skill build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

While historians once propagated the myth that Africans who were brought to the New World as slaves contributed little of value but their labor, a recent study by Amelia Wallace Vernon helps to dispel this notion by showing that Africans introduced rice and the methods of cultivating it into what is now the United States in the early eighteenth century.

Topic

The introduction of rice cultivation to the United States by Africans and the cultural and historical significance of African American rice farming.

Framework

Old / New, Highlight Noteworthy

Main Point

Recent research overturns the long-standing myth that Africans brought as slaves contributed little besides labor, showing that they introduced rice and rice cultivation techniques to the U.S., and that rice farming continued for complex cultural and symbolic reasons even after slavery ended. ( — first sentence)

P1: Dispelling the Myth – Africans Introduced Rice Cultivation

A new study by Amelia Wallace Vernon directly contradicts the old idea that African slaves only contributed labor, showing instead that they brought both rice and rice farming know-how to early America. She uses historical documents, such as a 1718 order for Africans who could cultivate rice, to support her claims, which overturn earlier attributions of rice introduction to French settlers.

P2: Why Did African Americans Grow Rice?

Vernon’s research looks into why African Americans continued to grow rice, even though the economy was focused on cotton. She finds that during slavery, plantation owners let or made slaves grow rice on unsuitable cotton land for their own consumption, and that rice farming let slaves work independently, away from supervision.

P3: Rice Cultivation After Slavery – A Puzzle

After emancipation, it became even less practical for Black farmers to grow rice—corn was more popular to eat, there was no market, and landlords accepted only cotton for rent. The effort needed to make land suitable for rice seemed to outweigh any reward, unless the act of transforming the land itself had significance.

25.

Which one of the following most completely and accurately describes the organization of the passage?

  1. A historical phenomenon is presented,

    Bad Last Ingredient

    We want the final ingredient to match up with Vernon's explanation for why freed African Americans grew rice. This says "one theory having the most support is settled upon". There aren't multiple theories in this passage. And the author isn't deciding that Vernon's is the right one. The author is just presenting Vernon's explanation.

    3% picked this

  2. A historical discovery is presented,

    Bad Last Ingredient

    We want the final ingredient to match up with Vernon's explanation for why freed African Americans grew rice. This ends with "two questions left unanswered". Both of the questions are answered, the 2nd one being answered in this final paragraph.

    11% picked this

  3. Correct

    A historical fact is presented,

    Why this is right

    We want the final ingredient to match up with Vernon's explanation for why freed African Americans grew rice. This says "two answers to the question are given". Since Vernon's explanation is answering the question "why did freed African Americans grow rice", this seems more workable than any other answer so let's see if we can match it up. In the 2nd and 3rd sentences of the of 2nd paragraph, we hear: At the heart of Vernon's research is the question of why African Americans grew rice. She proposes two intriguing answers, depending on whether the time is before or after the end of slavery. So we can definitely match up "a question is raised, and two answers are given", and those two answers take us all the way through the end of the passage because the final paragraph was the 2nd answer to the question. Can we match up the 1st ingredient? Did the passage begin with "a historical fact"? Sure, it's a little weird, but the historical fact seems to be that African Americans, not French Acadians, seem to have been the first people in America with knowledge of how to cultivate rice.

    Skill tested: Organization · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.

    72% picked this

  4. A historical question is raised,

    Bad Last Ingredient

    We want the final ingredient to match up with Vernon's explanation for why freed African Americans grew rice. This says "two reasons for difficulty in answering the question are given". The passage is ending with an answer to the 2nd question, not with reasons for why answering the question is difficult.

    6% picked this

  5. A historical question is raised,

    Bad Last Ingredient

    We want the final ingredient to match up with Vernon's explanation for why freed African Americans grew rice. This says "a number issues surrounding the study are discussed". The final paragraph doesn't have any commentary from our author about issues surrounding Vernon's study. It's just presenting Vernon's explanation for why African Americans grew rice, even once they were emancipated.

    7% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free