Reading ComprehensionDifficulty: Hard

PT155 S3 P3 Q19 Explanation

Nanoscale Computer Chips

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

TopicsAnalogyScience

Keep going in LSAT Lab

  • Save & drill this skill build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Full official LSAT questions are available through LawHub. This page provides LSAT Lab's explanation, strategy, and review tools without republishing the full official question.

Passage

This passage was adapted from an article published

Competition to make computer chips smaller and, consequently, faster and more efficient has driven a technological revolution, fueled economic growth, and rapidly made successive generations of computers obsolete. Yet at the current rate of progress this march toward miniaturization will hit a wall by about 2010—for many, an unthinkable prospect. The laws are investigating a different molecular pattern maker: peptides, amino acid chains that are shorter than proteins.

The project grew out of Belcher’s doctoral research on abalone. Her research group discovered in the mid-1990s that a specific peptide causes calcium carbonate to crystallize into the structure found only in the tough abalone shell. From that discovery, Belcher and Hu, Belcher’s postdoctoral adviser at the time, realized that if they resembling accelerated evolution, they developed additional related peptides from those that had the initially promising characteristics.

Hu says that in order to use such a method to assemble a set of circuit-building tools it would be necessary to identify many additional organic compounds that bind to circuit-component materials. The group is making progress on that quest. As they have expanded their targets to 20 more semiconductor materials, their glue. It will take that kind of finesse at the nanoscale to produce selfassembling circuits.

What this question is testing

Analogy

Topic

The author is profiling a piece of chemistry research aimed at solving a problem the computer industry is about to run into.

Framework

Highlight Noteworthy. The author isn't fighting an opponent — they're explaining why this research matters and where it stands.

Main Point

Here's the simpler version: computer chips have been getting smaller every year, but that march is about to hit a physical wall — transistors can't shrink below 25 nanometers using current techniques. Living cells, though, build smaller structures all the time. So scientists are looking to biology for tools. Belcher and Hu are betting on peptides (short amino-acid chains): they've found peptides that can grab onto specific semiconductor crystals and even act like molecular glue. That's the kind of fine-grained tool you'd need to build circuits that assemble themselves at the nanoscale.

P1: A wall is coming, and biology might help

Chips have been getting smaller, faster, cheaper — but at the current rate, this hits a wall by about 2010. The laws of physics say current transistors can't go below 25 nanometers. Cells, however, build complex structures smaller than that all the time. So the question is whether we can harness those biological processes. Most researchers focus on DNA. Belcher and Hu are working with peptides instead.

P2: How the idea developed

Belcher had been studying abalone shells and found a peptide that controls how calcium carbonate crystallizes there. She and Hu reasoned: if we can find peptides that control crystal growth in semiconductor materials, we'd have a tool for building tiny electronics. No such peptide was known, so they took the bold approach of growing a billion random peptides and testing which ones grabbed onto silicon, gallium arsenide, or indium phosphide crystals. They found a handful, and then refined them by a process resembling evolution.

P3: Where the project is now

To make a real toolkit they'd need many more binding peptides. They're getting there — hundreds of them, across 20+ materials. They're also designing peptides that latch onto two different crystals at once, which acts like a tiny dab of glue. That kind of precision is what circuits that build themselves will need.

Reading along? Open the full official question in LawHub — we show a fragment here and keep the reasoning in our own words.

The question
19.

Which one of the following situations involving volatile oils is most analogous to the situation involving peptides that is

Answer choices

  1. Bad Match: abandons inquiry2% picked this

    A group of researchers, whose experimentation has focused on the chemical properties of certain synthetic volatile oils, abandons that line of inquiry on receiving

    If "volatile oils" is playing the role of "peptides", then this is saying that Belcher was working on peptides and then received a grant to study something else altogether.

  2. Bad Match: powerful insecticide12% picked this

    A group of researchers extracts several volatile oils from the leaves of certain species of trees and, while testing each of the oils to

    The idea of testing each volatile oil to determine whether it has properties that could make it useful to human applications would be similar to testing peptides to see whether they have properties (binding to semiconductor materials) that would make them useful to human computing applications. But this is saying during that phase, they discover that the oil can actually be used for something else. In the passage, as Belcher and Hu were testing peptides for use in computing, they didn't suddenly discover that one of the peptides was good for something else.

  3. Bad Match: when combined13% picked this

    A group of researchers synthesizes several volatile oils that, when combined, are found to be useful as a fungicide on fruit trees. Through further

    This is talking about making several volatile oils in the lab that are useful when combined. The peptides that Belcher and Hu found were responsive to semiconductor materials were responsive on their own. They didn't need to be combined to be useful. This answer also involves a further experiment and a completely different usage. Belcher and Hu didn't have any completely different usage. All their experimentation was aimed at designing nano-circuits.

  4. Bad Match: used in medical applications9% picked this

    A group of researchers observes that a volatile oil contained in an antifungal product used on fruit trees can cause mutations in the trees.

    This answer starts off like a good match for Belcher's abalone epiphany. We have researchers studying a natural object and discovering a funky property of a volatile oil. Then they launch a project (like Belcher and Hu did). But in Belcher and Hu's case, the project was to make and test new peptides to see if any could be used in human computing applications. In this answer choice, the project was to test existing volatile oils that were already being used in human applications.

  5. Correct64% picked this

    A group of researchers, noting that a volatile oil secreted by a certain species of tree protects it from a type of fungal infection,

    Why this is right

    This answer starts off as a good match for Belcher's abalone epiphany. We have researchers studying a natural object and discovering a funky property of a volatile oil. That funky property makes us think of a potential human application. Next, we start trying to make/synthesize our own volatile oils (just like B&H started making their own peptides) and test them to see whether each one would work for our human purpose.

    Skill tested: Analogy · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free