In a study, six medical students were each separately presented with the same patient, whose symptoms could be the result of any one of several medical conditions.
Facts
Some med students and a doctor are looking at a sick patient trying to diagnose.
The doctor says,
A week later these same med students and a different doctor are looking at a similar sick patient.
The new doctor says, "Well, how would we diagnose this patient?" Meg says, "here's how I would rule out lupus ..." Tony says, "here's how I would rule out emphysema ... "
Evaluate
This one seems to be like a Solve the Causal Mystery / Identify the Causal Difference-Maker type setup. We have some interesting behavior in that each med student is going back to the disease they were asked about initially.
Can we say something safely worded like, , or
Goal
Pick the most provable answer (it might be a safely worded explanation for why the med students are going back to their original diagnosis).