Reading ComprehensionDifficulty: Medium

PT141 S1 P2 Q8 Explanation

Julia Margaret Cameron

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

TopicsMain PointHumanities

Keep going in LSAT Lab

  • Save & drill this skill build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Full official LSAT questions are available through LawHub. This page provides LSAT Lab's explanation, strategy, and review tools without republishing the full official question.

Passage

From a critical discussion of the work of Victorian photographer Cameron.

What Cameron called her “fancy-subject” pictures—photographs in which two or more costumed sitters enacted, under Cameron’s direction, scenes from the Bible, mythology, Shakespeare, or Tennyson—bear unmistakable traces of the often comical conditions under which they were taken. In many respects they have more connection to the family album pictures of recalcitrant relatives Oscar Gustave Rejlander’s extravagantly awful The Two Ways of Life—rather than among its most vital images.

It is precisely the camera’s realism—its stubborn obsession with the surface of things—that has given Cameron’s theatricality and artificiality its atmosphere of truth. It is the truth of the sitting, rather than the fiction which all the dressing up was in aid of, that wafts out of these wonderful and strange, not-quite-in-focus only Lear or Medea. Still photographs of theatrical scenes can never escape being pictures of actors.

What gives Cameron’s pictures of actors their special quality—their status as treasures of photography of an unfathomably peculiar sort—is their singular combination of amateurism and artistry. In The Passing of Arthur, for example, the mast and oar of the makeshift boat representing a royal barge are obviously broomsticks and the water is puts one in mind of good amateur theatricals one has seen, and recalls with shameless delight.

What this question is testing

Main Point

Your task

Capture the passage's overall primary point — the claim everything else supports.

Common trap

Answers that are true but too narrow (a single paragraph) or too broad (beyond the passage's scope).

Winning move

Summarize the whole passage in one sentence first, then match it to a choice.

Reading along? Open the full official question in LawHub — we show a fragment here and keep the reasoning in our own words.

The question
8.

Which one of the following most accurately expresses the main point of

Answer choices

  1. Too Narrow6% picked this

    The circumstances under which Cameron's fancy-subject pictures were taken render them

    This answer says something true and supportable from the passage, but it somewhat misses the mark of the Main Point, because it isn't complimentary enough (or at all). The author is trying to convey that even though Cameron's efforts fail and we can see right through the charade, her work nonetheless is captivating. They have "status as treasures of photography of an unfathomably peculiar sort". This answer conveys the comically peculiar part, but it's not giving us any of the unfathomable treasure part.

  2. Correct76% picked this

    The peculiar charm of Cameron's fancy-subject pictures derives from the viewer's simultaneous awareness of the fictional scene portrayed and

    Why this is right

    This aligns well with our Most Valuable Sentence (the first one of the last paragraph). It compliments Cameron's work for its peculiar charm. That sentence says the special charm comes from a unique combination of amateurism and artistry. The artistry is the fictional scene portrayed (the magical and mysterious night scene of Passing of Arthur, for example). The amateurism is the circumstances of its portrayal (the mast and oar are obviously broomsticks). The viewer's simultaneous awareness matches up with the end of the 2nd paragraph: we are always aware of the photographs doubleness -- of each figure's imaginary and real personas.

    Skill tested: Main Point · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.

  3. Contradicted: undermined5% picked this

    The implicit charm of Cameron's fancy-subject pictures to comparison with the masterpieces of Western painting is undermined by

    The author thinks that the obtrusiveness of the sitters' displeasure with the sitting is a crucial element in the resulting experience of viewing Cameron's photos. The author says that if she had succeeded in what she was trying to do (i.e. if her actors had not "ruined" her attempts to re-create grandiose scenes), she would be forgettable. What makes her images vital is how the photographic medium reveals the truth of the sitting and makes us aware of the doubleness of each sitter's real and fictional personas.

  4. Too Strong: most successful Opposite: unaware3% picked this

    The most successful of Cameron's fancy-subject pictures from an aesthetic point of view are those in which the viewer is completely unaware that the

    We can pretty much bail as soon as we see "The most successful of Cameron's pictures", because the author never singled out any as the tops. Overall, this answer is wrong for the same reason that (C) was. This answer is making it seem like Cameron's photos are better if you're not aware of the obtrusive sitters. The author was saying the opposite. The author thinks that the obtrusiveness of the sitters' displeasure with the sitting is a crucial element in the resulting experience of viewing Cameron's photos. Our awareness of both what Cameron was trying to achieve and what her recalcitrant models would let her achieve is what creates this singular combination of artistry and amateurism, and that combo is what makes Cameron's photos special.

  5. Too Narrow10% picked this

    The interest of Cameron's fancy-subject pictures consists in what they tell us about the sitters and not in

    This is similar to (A), in that it's focused on the unintentionally comic realities of the sitters. But the thesis is about the singular combination of artistry and amateurism; it's about the doubleness of each figure's imaginary and real personas. This answer makes it seem like the author thinks that all we should be paying attention to when we look at Cameron's photos are the sitters. But the author thinks that Cameron's peculiar charm comes from the combination of theatricality and artificiality.

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free