Reading Comprehension

PT120 · S2 · P1 · Q5 The Downstate Campaign

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

Save & drill this skill — build targeted practice sets from questions like this one
Video walkthroughs — watch every question solved step by step
81 official LSATs — as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

In 1963, a three-week-long demonstration for jobs at the construction site of the Downstate Medical Center in Brooklyn, New York, became one of the most significant and widely publicized campaigns of the civil rights movement in the United States.

Topic

The 1963 Downstate Medical Center protest in Brooklyn led by African American ministers and its impact on the civil rights movement.

Framework

Highlight Noteworthy (with a touch of Problem / Solution)

Main Point

The Downstate Medical Center protest was a milestone civil rights action led by politically moderate African American ministers, who balanced activism with continued engagement in established political channels; this set a precedent for future civil rights leadership in northern cities. The key "Most Valuable Sentence" encapsulating the main point appears near the end of the last paragraph:

P1: Introduction to the Downstate Protest

This paragraph introduces the Downstate protest as an influential and widely publicized civil rights campaign in Brooklyn. It highlights the unusual leadership of locally based, previously moderate African American ministers, describes how they organized and funded the protest through their congregations, and outlines their goal of forcing changes to discriminatory government and union hiring policies.

P2: The Ministers’ Role and the Risks They Took

Here we learn why national civil rights organization CORE encouraged the ministers to lead the protest and how the ministers' involvement broke with their traditionally moderate, politically connected roles. The paragraph discusses the tension between their new activism and their established positions, emphasizing that by leading the protest, they risked losing political influence and community trust.

P3: Outcomes and Broader Significance

The final paragraph sums up the results: although the protest didn't achieve all its demands, it did secure promises to enforce existing anti-discrimination laws and brought public attention to job discrimination in the North. Critically, the ministers preserved their moderate standing while being effective activists, creating a model for future civil rights leadership.

The passage most clearly suggests that which one of the following is true of the group of ministers who led the Downstate campaign?

Correct
The Downstate campaign did not
Why this is right
This is tricky because the Downstate campaign did signal a significant change in their tactics. They went from being moderate intermediaries between community and government to being "radical" civil disobedient protesters. But it didn't change their goals. In the middle of the 2nd paragraph, it says that, "Urban African American ministers and churches had been working for decades with community and government organizations to address the social, political, and economic concerns of their communities". The goal of the Downstate campaign (end of 1st paragraph) was "to build a mass movement that would force changes in government policies as well as in trade union hiring practices, which they felt were excluding African Americans". So are the political / social goals of the Downstate campaign in a similar realm to "addressing the social, political, and economic concerns of their communities?" Sure -- trying to get jobs is definitely an economic concern. And feeling like you're being marginalized because you're African American is a social / political concern.
Skill tested: Inference · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.
50% picked this
After the Downstate campaign, they
Out of Scope: various other campaigns
The aftermath described towards the end of the final paragraph doesn't mention anything about organizing various other similar campaigns. We know they "continued to work through established political channels", but by definition that would not be a similar campaign. This was an aggressive protest of civil disobedience, not the old school way they would moderately influence the community through established channels.
9% picked this
They had come together for
Unsupported: earlier construction efforts
We're told that they had previously come together to work for their communities (albeit in more moderate ways), but we were never told anything as specific as "they previously worked to address problems in the construction history". All we know is that they previously worked "to address the social, political, and economic concerns of their communities". Finally, if this answer were true, then it would guarantee that choice (A) was also true (if they had previously addressed problems in the construction industry, then it's certainly fair to say that Downstate was not a significant switch to their goals). When answer X implies answer Y, then answer X can't possibly be correct because there can't be two correct answers.
9% picked this
They were criticized both by
Out of Scope: criticized
In the 3rd sentence of the last paragraph, we hear that some activists considered the agreement reached to be incomplete, but we're never told anything resembling the idea that CORE actually criticized these ministers who responded to their call for help.
2% picked this
Prior to the Downstate campaign,
Contradicted, if anything
We're told that prior to this campaign, they had for decades worked to address social, political, and economic concerns of their communities, via established political channels. We don't know for sure if those social / political / economic concerns involved civil rights activities, but we definitely are never told that it didn't involve civil rights. We have no textual ammunition to support this language that many of them had never engaged in civil rights activities before. We're even told that "elsewhere in the civil rights movement, African American religious leaders had emerged as key figures".
29% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

Save and practice this skill

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free