Reading ComprehensionDifficulty: Medium

PT116 S4 P3 Q19 Explanation

Native American Autobiography

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

TopicsApplicationHumanities

Keep going in LSAT Lab

  • Save & drill this skill build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Full official LSAT questions are available through LawHub. This page provides LSAT Lab's explanation, strategy, and review tools without republishing the full official question.

Passage

In studying the autobiographies of Native Americans, most scholars have focused on as-told-to life histories that were solicited, translated, recorded, and edited by non-Native American collaborators—that emerged from “bicultural composite authorship”. Limiting their studies to such written documents, these scholars have overlooked traditional, preliterate modes of communicating personal history. In addition, they and writing that underlie the concept of an autobiography—that indeed constitute the English word’s root meaning.

The idea of self was, in a number of pre-contact Native American cultures, markedly inclusive: identity was not merely individual, but also relational to a society, a specific landscape, and the cosmos. Within these cultures, the expression of life experiences tended to be oriented toward current events: with the participation of fellow one person might require the enactment of that vision in the form of a tribal pageant.

One can view as autobiographical the elaborate tattoos that symbolized a warrior’s valorous deeds, and such artifacts as a decorated shield that communicated the accomplishments and aspirations of its maker, or a robe that was emblazoned with the pictographic history of the wearer’s battles and was sometimes used in reenactments. Also autobiographical, of its owner, who was often assisted in the painting by other tribal members.

A tribe would, then, have contributed to the individual’s narrative not merely passively, by its social codes and expectations, but actively by joining in the expression of that narrative. Such intercultural collaboration may seem alien to the European style of autobiography, yet any autobiography is shaped by its creator’s ideas about the additionally have been shaped by the cultural perspectives of the people who transmitted them.

What this question is testing

Application

Your task

Pin down exactly what the question asks about the passage — a detail, the author's view, the structure, or the main point — before looking at the choices.

Common trap

Answers that restate a true detail from the passage but don't answer the specific question being asked.

Winning move

Anticipate the answer in your own words from the passage, then find the choice that matches that prediction.

Reading along? Open the full official question in LawHub — we show a fragment here and keep the reasoning in our own words.

The question
19.

Which one of the following would be most consistent with the ideas about identity that the author attributes to

Answer choices

  1. Opposite, if anything4% picked this

    A person who is born into one tribe but is brought up by members of another tribe retains

    This doesn't reinforce any of the central ideas about Native American concepts of identity or autobiography. And, if anything, it seems like it would be more consistent for a Native American to get a "new name" when a seminal life event happened, like switching tribes. We're told at the end of the 2nd paragraph about "the process whereby one repeatedly took on new names to reflect important events and deeds in one's life".

  2. Correct74% picked this

    A pictograph that represents a specific person incorporates the symbol for

    Why this is right

    The fact that "a specific person is represented by the symbol for a constellation" reinforces that idea that their concept of identify was "not merely individual, but also relational to a society, a specific landscape, and the cosmos". The fact that someone's identity is being captured in a pictograph also resonates with the 3rd paragraph, in which personal deeds or qualities are captured in tangible form on objects such as tattoos / shields / robes / tepees.

    Skill tested: Application · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.

  3. Out of Scope12% picked this

    A similar ritual for assuming a new name is used in

    Out of Scope: similar used in diverse We're told at the end of the 1st paragraph about "the cultural constructs of the highly diverse Native American peoples". The fact that these peoples were highly diverse, by common sense, makes it unlikely for them to have very similar customs or rituals. The beginning of the 2nd also implies variety: "The idea of self was, in a number of pre-contact Native American cultures, markedly inclusive". It's not that this answer is contradicted. It's possible that similar rituals for new names took place across diverse communities. But we don't have any support text we can match up with this answer.

  4. Too Strong: cannot5% picked this

    A name given to one member of a community cannot be given to another member

    We don't know enough about how various pre-contact cultures thought about names to say that they would have forbidden two people in the same community from having the same name. Maybe that's true, but what text are we pointing to in order to support this?

  5. Too Strong: cannot5% picked this

    A decorated shield that belonged to an individual cannot be traced to

    This is very similar to (D). If we can't trace a shield back to a particular tribe, that implies that the shield didn't have any distinctive features that are associated with a particular tribe (or that it had distinctive features that are associated with multiple tribes). We don't know enough about how shields were decorated to say if tribes had such a signature style that it would be apparent which tribe a given shield had come from, or not.

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free