Logical Reasoning

PT112 · S4 · Q7 Critic: Emily Dickinson’s poetry

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Logical Reasoning question.

  • Save & drill this skill — build targeted practice sets from questions like this one

  • Video walkthroughs — watch every question solved step by step

  • 81 official LSATs — as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

Start practicing free

Critic: Emily Dickinson’s poetry demonstrates that meaning cannot reside entirely within a poem itself, but is always the unique result of an interaction between a reader’s system of beliefs and the poem; and, of course, any two readers from different cultures or eras have radically different systems of beliefs.

Premises

(1) Meaning in a Dickinson poem cannot reside entirely within the poem itself; it always emerges from the interaction between a reader's system of beliefs and the poem. (2) Any two readers from different cultures or eras have radically different systems of beliefs.

Evaluate

This is an EXCEPT question — four answers could be true, and one cannot. Combine the two premises: meaning depends on the interaction between reader and poem, AND readers from different cultures or eras have radically different belief systems. So when those readers each interact with the same poem, they're combining the same poem with radically different belief systems, which produces meanings that result from radically different interactions. The claim that two such readers interpret a poem the same way is incompatible with this — the belief systems are radically different, so the meanings they generate cannot be identical.

Goal

Find the answer that says two readers from different eras interpret a poem the same way — that's the one ruled out.

7.

If the critic's statements are true, each of the following could be true EXCEPT:

  1. A reader’s interpretation of a

    Could Be True

    The premises don't restrict whether a reader can be influenced by another person's interpretation. A reader's belief system can be shaped by interactions with other people. Nothing in the stimulus rules this out.

    11% picked this

  2. Correct

    A modern reader and a

    Why this is right

    This is the answer that cannot be true. A modern reader and a nineteenth-century reader are from different eras. By premise (2), they have radically different belief systems. By premise (1), the meaning each derives from a Shakespeare sonnet is the product of that reader's belief system + the poem. Run radically different belief systems through the same poem, and you cannot get the same interpretation. (B) describes exactly this — same interpretation across radically different eras — which the framework rules out.

    Skill tested: Must be False · how this choice captures the argument's function is the move to repeat next time.

    77% picked this

  3. A reader’s interpretation of a

    Could Be True

    A reader's belief system can change over time, and the premises don't rule out a reader's own interpretation evolving. Nothing in the stimulus prevents this — it's consistent with meaning being the product of the reader's belief system at the moment of reading.

    1% picked this

  4. Two readers from the same

    Could Be True

    The premises only specify that different cultures or eras produce radically different belief systems. They don't say readers from the same era have identical belief systems. So two same-era readers can absolutely differ in interpretation. Consistent with the stimulus.

    2% picked this

  5. A reader’s enjoyment of a

    Could Be True

    The stimulus is about how meaning arises, not about what enhances a reader's enjoyment. There's no contradiction in saying a reader's enjoyment goes up when they learn the poet's own take. Nothing here is ruled out.

    9% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

Save and practice this skill
LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free