Reading Comprehension

PT109 · S2 · P2 · Q10 Domestic Novels

A free, expert breakdown of this official LSAT Reading Comprehension question.

Save & drill this skill — build targeted practice sets from questions like this one
Video walkthroughs — watch every question solved step by step
81 official LSATs — as questions, timed sections & full-length tests

The autobiographical narrative Incidents in the Life of a Slave Girl, Written by Herself (1861), by Harriet A. Jacobs, a slave of African descent, not only recounts an individual life but also provides, implicitly and explicitly, a perspective on the larger United States culture from the viewpoint of one denied access to it.

Topic

The way Harriet Jacobs’s slave narrative uses and challenges the conventions of the sentimental domestic novel to highlight the unique struggles of enslaved women.

Framework

Challenge Position

Main Point

Jacobs uses the familiar conventions of the domestic novel in her autobiography to reach female readers, but in doing so she reframes and challenges the genre’s values, showing that the ideals of marriage, home, and family are not always attainable or meaningful for enslaved women. (Most Valuable Sentences: end of P2, especially, )

P1: Jacobs’s Strategic Use of the Domestic Novel

Jacobs carefully crafts her autobiography to mimic the sentimental domestic novel, emphasizing values like marriage and family, so her female readers will empathize with her plight and recognize that enslaved women cherish the same ideals.

P2: Critics’ Objections and Jacobs’s Subversion of the Genre

Some critics think Jacobs compromised her experiences by sticking to convention, but the passage argues that her work actually exposes the limits of the genre. By highlighting the harsh realities faced by enslaved women—like losing her lover and family—Jacobs shows that the typical values of the domestic novel exclude women like her. Ultimately, her autobiography becomes an “antidomestic novel” that calls out why those values don’t fit her lived experience, urging readers to reconsider the genre’s assumptions.

10.

It can most reasonably be inferred from the passage that the critics mentioned at the start of the second paragraph hold which one of the following views?

The mixture of literary genres
Opposite
Our author and Jacobs probably think that mixing two genres (domestic novel and slave narrative) created a useful tension. But these critics are saying that Jacobs' mistake was mixing the two genres.
2% picked this
The mixture of literary genres
Too Strong: both
We could have signed off on an answer that said, "tends to cause the goals of at least one genre to be compromised". The critics didn't say that readers won't get the domestic novel effect and won't get the slave narrative effect. They just said the slave narrative will get overshadowed by the domestic novel.
7% picked this
The mixture of literary genres
Opposite
Which has a greater degree of realism: slave narratives or domestic novels? If the answer is, "who's to say", then we can get rid of this answer simply by not knowing how to even apply it to the conversation at hand. But the common sense answer would seemingly be that slave narratives are more realistic, as they detailed the terrible conditions of slavery. Domestic novels idealized the romance and intrigue of society women and their drama. So if mixing genres favored the more realistic, then the slave narrative would overshadow the domestic novel. But the critics believe the opposite of that.
2% picked this
The mixture of literary genres
Opposite
Which has a lesser degree of realism: slave narratives or domestic novels? If the answer is, "who's to say", then we can get rid of this answer simply by not knowing how to even apply it to the conversation at hand. But the common sense answer would seemingly be that slave narratives are less sentimental, since they are describing harrowing times spent in slavery. Domestic novels idealized the romance and intrigue of society women and their drama, so when the protagonist gets a crush on someone or is heartbroken with love, one would expect a lot of sentimentality. So if mixing genres favored the less sentimental, then the slave narrative would overshadow the domestic novel. But the critics believe the opposite of that.
2% picked this
Correct
The mixture of literary genres
Why this is right
We love the soft, supportable language of "mixing genres can sometimes cause the goals of one genre to be compromised". Can we support this from our two ideas: - by conforming to convention, Jacobs shortchanged her own experiences - the purposes of the domestic novel overshadow those of the typical slave narrative Yes, the 2nd detail sounds like it's saying that mixing a domestic novel and a slave narrative together caused the slave narrative to be compromised (it was overshadowed and it shortchanged Jacobs's ability to relay her experiences).
Skill tested: Non-Author Opinion · how this choice captures the passage's function is the move to repeat next time.
86% picked this

Continue the review in LSAT Lab

Save this question, watch the video walkthrough, and drill similar questions in your LSAT Lab account.

Save and practice this skill

LSAT Lab

Turn this review into a targeted study plan.

Save this question, drill more like it, watch the video walkthrough, and track your progress in your LSAT Lab account.

Start practicing free